JCL Tutorial

JCL Coding Standards

Best practices for creating maintainable, consistent, and reliable JCL code

Progress0 of 0 lessons

Why JCL Coding Standards Matter

JCL (Job Control Language) plays a crucial role in mainframe operations, serving as the bridge between applications and the operating system. Unlike application code which might be completely rewritten over time, JCL often persists for decades, surviving multiple system upgrades and application changes.

Well-structured JCL coding standards provide several significant benefits:

Maintainability

Consistent JCL is easier to understand and modify, reducing the time needed for maintenance and troubleshooting.

Knowledge Transfer

Standards facilitate knowledge sharing and reduce the learning curve for new team members.

Error Reduction

Following established patterns helps prevent common errors and improves overall reliability.

Operational Efficiency

Standardized JCL makes automation, monitoring, and management more consistent and reliable.

In enterprise environments, JCL often outlives the developers who wrote it. Clear standards ensure that JCL remains maintainable throughout its lifecycle, which can span decades.

Naming Conventions

Consistent naming conventions make JCL more intuitive, making it easier to identify the purpose and relationship between different components. Well-designed naming standards provide immediate context about each element's function.

Job Names

Job names should follow a structured pattern that provides information about the job's purpose and ownership:

Recommended Pattern: AAAFNNNX

AAA - Application or department identifier (e.g., PAY for payroll, FIN for finance)
F - Function code (e.g., D for daily, R for report, B for backup)
NNN - Sequence number (e.g., 001, 002)
X - Optional environment indicator (e.g., P for production, T for test, D for development)

Example: PAYR001P - Payroll report #1 for production

Step Names

Step names should be descriptive and indicate the function of the step:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
//JOBNAME  JOB (ACCT),'JOB TITLE',CLASS=A
//*--------------------------------------------------
//EXTRACT  EXEC PGM=DBEXTRACT
//...
//SORT     EXEC PGM=SORT
//...
//REPORT   EXEC PGM=REPORTER
//...

Use consistent step names across similar jobs to make it easier to compare and troubleshoot.

Procedure Names

Procedure names should follow similar conventions to job names but may be more specific to their function:

Recommended Pattern: AAANNFFF

AAA - Application identifier
NN - Optional sequence number
FFF - Function description (e.g., BKP for backup, RPT for report)

Example: PAY01RPT - Payroll report procedure #1

Dataset Names

Dataset naming is critical for organization and should follow a structured approach:

Recommended Pattern: HLQ.AAA.TYPE.CONTENT.QUALIFIER

HLQ - High-level qualifier (often company or environment)
AAA - Application identifier
TYPE - Data type (e.g., DATA, JCL, PROC, RPT)
CONTENT - Specific content descriptor
QUALIFIER - Optional additional qualifiers (e.g., DAILY, BACKUP)

Example: PROD.PAY.DATA.EMPLOYEE.MASTER

Important: Document your naming conventions and enforce them consistently. In large organizations, maintain a centralized registry of application and function codes to prevent duplicates.

Documentation Standards

Comprehensive documentation is essential for long-term JCL maintainability. Even the most well-written JCL requires context and explanation to understand its purpose, requirements, and relationships to other components.

Job Header Documentation

Every JCL job should begin with a standardized header that provides essential information:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
//*====================================================================
//* JOB NAME: PAYR001P
//* PURPOSE:  GENERATE MONTHLY PAYROLL REPORTS
//* AUTHOR:   JANE DOE
//* CREATED:  2023-01-15
//*
//* SCHEDULE: RUNS ON THE LAST BUSINESS DAY OF EACH MONTH
//* DEPENDENCIES: REQUIRES EMPLOYEE MASTER FILE UPDATE (PAYUPD01P)
//*              TO COMPLETE SUCCESSFULLY
//*
//* SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS:
//*  - SET REPORT PERIOD PARAMETER IN STEP 'SETDATE'
//*
//* CHANGE HISTORY:
//* 2023-01-15 J.DOE   INITIAL CREATION
//* 2023-03-22 J.SMITH ADDED TAX CALCULATION STEP
//*====================================================================
//PAYR001P JOB (ACCT),'MONTHLY PAYROLL',CLASS=A,NOTIFY=&SYSUID
//...

Essential Header Elements

Job Name and Purpose - What the job does and why it exists
Author and Creation Date - Who created it and when
Schedule Information - When the job runs and any timing dependencies
Dependencies - Other jobs or resources that must be available
Special Instructions - Any parameters or considerations needed to run the job
Change History - Record of modifications with dates and reasons

Section and Step Documentation

Use clear comments to separate logical sections and explain the purpose of each step:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//* STEP 1: EXTRACT EMPLOYEE DATA
//* Purpose: Pull current employee records from master file
//* Output:  TEMP.EMPLOYEE.EXTRACT
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//EXTRACT  EXEC PGM=DBEXTRACT
//SYSPRINT DD SYSOUT=*
//MASTER   DD DSN=PROD.PAY.DATA.EMPLOYEE.MASTER,DISP=SHR
//EXTRACT  DD DSN=&&TEMP.EMPLOYEE.EXTRACT,
//            DISP=(NEW,PASS,DELETE),
//            SPACE=(CYL,(10,5),RLSE)
//SYSIN    DD *
  EXTRACT ALL WHERE STATUS='ACTIVE'
/*

Inline Documentation

Add specific comments for complex or non-obvious statements:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
//PAYROLL  EXEC PGM=PAYRUN
//* The larger region is needed for end-of-year processing
//         REGION=0M
//INFILE   DD DSN=PROD.PAY.DATA.INPUTS,DISP=SHR
//* Override the standard tax rate file for special processing
//TAXRATES DD DSN=PROD.PAY.DATA.TAXRATE.SPECIAL,DISP=SHR

Procedure Documentation

Procedures require particularly thorough documentation since they're designed for reuse:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
//*====================================================================
//* PROCEDURE: PAYRPT
//* PURPOSE:   GENERATE STANDARD PAYROLL REPORTS
//*
//* PARAMETERS:
//*   PERIOD   - Reporting period (YYYYMM format)
//*   DETAIL   - Detail level (FULL/SUMMARY)
//*   OUTCLASS - Output class for reports (default: A)
//*
//* USAGE EXAMPLE:
//*   //STEP1  EXEC PAYRPT,PERIOD=202301,DETAIL=FULL
//*====================================================================
//PAYRPT   PROC PERIOD=,DETAIL=SUMMARY,OUTCLASS=A
//...

Treat documentation as a first-class citizen in your JCL. Well-documented JCL significantly reduces maintenance costs and minimizes operational risks.

Formatting Guidelines

Consistent formatting dramatically improves JCL readability. Well-formatted JCL is easier to scan, understand, and modify, reducing the chance of errors and making troubleshooting more efficient.

Statement Structure

Follow these guidelines for statement structure:

Start statements in column 1 or 2 (// or /)
For primary statements (JOB, EXEC, DD), align the operation field consistently
Align parameter fields for visual scanning
For comments, use //* and align the text consistently
Use blank comment lines to separate logical sections

Continuation Guidelines

When JCL statements require continuation:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
//STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM,
//             PARM='OPTION1,
//             OPTION2,
//             OPTION3'
//OUTDD    DD  DSN=MY.OUTPUT.DATASET,
//             DISP=(NEW,CATLG,DELETE),
//             SPACE=(CYL,(10,5),RLSE),
//             DCB=(RECFM=FB,LRECL=80,BLKSIZE=0)

Note how the continuation lines:

Start with // in columns 1-2
Have consistent indentation for the continued parameters
Maintain parameter groups on the same line when possible
End complete parameter groups with commas

Consistent Indentation

Use indentation to highlight structure and relationships:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
//CONDITL JOB (ACCT),'CONDITIONAL JOB',CLASS=A
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
// IF (RC = 0) THEN
//   STEP1A  EXEC PGM=PROGRAM1
//   STEP1B  EXEC PGM=PROGRAM2
// ELSE
//   STEP2A  EXEC PGM=ALTPROG1
//   STEP2B  EXEC PGM=ALTPROG2
// ENDIF
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
// IF (STEP1B.RC < 8) THEN
//   PROCESS EXEC PGM=REGULAR
// ELSE
//   RECOVER EXEC PGM=BACKUP
// ENDIF

Parameter Grouping and Order

Arrange parameters in a consistent, logical order:

For DD Statements:

Dataset identification (DSN, DISP)
Space allocation parameters (SPACE, VOL)
Dataset attributes (DCB)
Special handling parameters (LABEL, UNIT)

For EXEC Statements:

Program or procedure identification (PGM, PROC)
Execution parameters (PARM)
Resource management (REGION, TIME)
Conditional execution (COND)

Example of Well-Formatted JCL

This example demonstrates many formatting best practices:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
//*====================================================================
//* JOB NAME: PAYR001P - MONTHLY PAYROLL PROCESSING
//* PURPOSE:  PROCESS MONTHLY PAYROLL AND GENERATE REPORTS
//* AUTHOR:   JANE DOE
//* CREATED:  2023-01-15
//*====================================================================
//PAYR001P JOB (ACCT),'MONTHLY PAYROLL',CLASS=A,
//             MSGCLASS=X,NOTIFY=&SYSUID
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//* STEP 1: EXTRACT EMPLOYEE DATA
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//EXTRACT  EXEC PGM=DBEXTRACT,REGION=0M
//SYSPRINT DD  SYSOUT=*
//MASTER   DD  DSN=PROD.PAY.DATA.EMPLOYEE.MASTER,DISP=SHR
//EXTRACT  DD  DSN=&&TEMP.EMPLOYEE.EXTRACT,
//             DISP=(NEW,PASS,DELETE),
//             SPACE=(CYL,(10,5),RLSE),
//             DCB=(RECFM=FB,LRECL=200,BLKSIZE=0)
//SYSIN    DD  *
  EXTRACT ALL WHERE STATUS='ACTIVE'
/*
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//* STEP 2: PROCESS PAYROLL CALCULATIONS
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//CALC     EXEC PGM=PAYCALC,COND=(0,LT,EXTRACT)
//SYSPRINT DD  SYSOUT=*
//INFILE   DD  DSN=&&TEMP.EMPLOYEE.EXTRACT,DISP=(OLD,PASS)
//TAXRATES DD  DSN=PROD.PAY.DATA.TAXRATES,DISP=SHR
//OUTFILE  DD  DSN=&&TEMP.PAYROLL.CALC,
//             DISP=(NEW,PASS,DELETE),
//             SPACE=(CYL,(15,5),RLSE)
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//* STEP 3: GENERATE REPORTS
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//REPORT   EXEC PGM=PAYRPT,COND=(0,LT,CALC)
//SYSPRINT DD  SYSOUT=*
//INFILE   DD  DSN=&&TEMP.PAYROLL.CALC,DISP=(OLD,DELETE)
//SUMMARY  DD  SYSOUT=A,DEST=PAYROLL
//DETAIL   DD  SYSOUT=A,DEST=PAYROLL
//SYSIN    DD  *
  REPORT TYPE=MONTHLY,DETAIL=YES
/*

Formatting Tip: Consider creating a JCL formatting template or style guide specific to your organization. Some mainframe editors offer formatting assistance features to help enforce standards.

Version Control Practices

Version control for JCL ensures that changes are tracked, can be reviewed, and can be reverted if necessary. Modern version control practices improve collaboration, provide audit trails, and enhance overall governance.

Traditional Mainframe Version Control

Traditional mainframe environments use specialized tools for version control:

CA Endevor

Enterprise-grade source control system with lifecycle management, promotion paths, and approvals specifically designed for mainframe environments.

IBM SCLM

Software Configuration and Library Manager integrated with ISPF for version control, build management, and deployment.

ChangeMan ZMF

Comprehensive change, configuration, and release management tool that supports the entire application lifecycle.

PanValet/Librarian

Legacy source code management systems that provide basic version control and member locking capabilities.

Modern Git-Based Approaches

Many organizations are adopting Git-based version control for JCL to align with DevOps practices:

Benefits of Git for JCL:

Integrated with modern DevOps toolchains
Distributed model allowing offline work
Robust branching and merging capabilities
Pull request workflows for code review
Integration with CI/CD pipelines

Implementation approaches include:

IBM Enterprise Git for z/OS - Native Git implementation for z/OS
Zowe - Open-source framework that includes Git integration
Custom synchronization - Tools that sync between Git repos and mainframe libraries

Version Control Best Practices

Regardless of the tool used, follow these best practices:

Store all JCL in version control - Avoid "shadow" JCL that exists only in production
Use meaningful commit messages - Describe what changed and why
Implement branch strategies - Use feature branches for significant changes
Require code reviews - Have another person review JCL changes before promotion
Maintain change history - Keep a log of all changes with business justification
Tag major releases - Create version tags for significant milestones
Automate where possible - Use tools to compare versions and identify differences

JCL Change History Block

Even with external version control, maintain a change history within the JCL itself:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
//*====================================================================
//* CHANGE HISTORY:
//* DATE       AUTHOR     CHANGE ID    DESCRIPTION
//* ---------- ---------- ------------ -----------------------------
//* 2023-01-15 JDOE       REQ12345     INITIAL CREATION
//* 2023-03-22 JSMITH     INC54321     ADDED TAX CALCULATION STEP
//* 2023-05-10 BJOHNSON   REQ67890     UPDATED FOR NEW TAX TABLES
//*====================================================================

While modern version control systems provide detailed change tracking, maintaining an inline history in the JCL itself provides immediate context without needing to access the version control system.

Change Management Considerations

Effective change management is crucial for JCL modifications, especially in production environments where changes can impact critical business operations. A structured approach reduces risk and ensures changes meet business needs.

The JCL Change Lifecycle

A well-defined change lifecycle includes these key phases:

1. Request & Approval

Document business need
Assess impact and risk
Obtain appropriate approvals

2. Development & Testing

Develop changes in dev environment
Test in controlled environments
Perform code reviews

3. Implementation & Verification

Schedule implementation
Follow migration procedures
Verify successful execution

Environment Promotion Path

JCL changes should follow a controlled promotion path through environments:

Environment	Purpose	Testing Focus	Approval Required
Development	Initial coding and testing	Basic functionality	Developer
Test/QA	Thorough testing	Integration and validation	QA Team
UAT	Business verification	Business requirements	Business Owner
Production	Live operations	Performance and stability	Change Board

JCL Change Documentation

Document each JCL change thoroughly with:

Change ID - Reference to ticket/request in change management system
Purpose - Clear explanation of why the change is needed
Description - What specifically is being changed
Rollback Plan - How to revert if issues occur
Testing Evidence - Results from test environments
Approvals - Record of who approved the change

Emergency Change Procedures

Even expedited changes should follow a structured process:

Identify the issue requiring emergency change
Obtain expedited approval from designated authority
Implement changes with minimum required testing
Document change completely after implementation
Conduct post-implementation review
Consider permanent fix if the emergency change was temporary

Important: Even urgent changes should never bypass documentation and approval entirely. Untracked changes create technical debt and increase operational risk.

Industry Best Practices

Beyond the specific standards discussed so far, these industry best practices can help you create and maintain high-quality JCL:

Modularity and Reusability

Embrace techniques that promote code reuse:

Develop cataloged procedures for common processing sequences
Use INCLUDE members for standard JCL fragments
Leverage symbolic parameters for flexibility
Create a library of standard components with documentation

Error Handling and Recovery

Design JCL with error recovery in mind:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
//JOBNAME  JOB (ACCT),'JOB TITLE',CLASS=A,
//         RESTART=STEP1
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
//STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM1
//...
//*--------------------------------------------------------------------
// IF STEP1.RC > 4 THEN
//   RECOVERY EXEC RECOVPROC,
//          STEP=STEP1,
//          ERRCODE=&STEP1.RC
// ENDIF

Key error handling practices include:

Use RESTART parameters to enable job restartability
Implement conditional logic for error scenarios
Create standardized error handling procedures
Use NOTIFY parameters to alert appropriate personnel
Include detailed error reporting steps

Resource Optimization

Optimize resource usage for better performance:

Use temporary datasets for intermediate results
Set appropriate REGION sizes without overallocating
Properly specify SPACE allocations with RLSE option
Use efficient DCB parameters with appropriate blocksizes
Clean up temporary resources at job completion

Security Considerations

Implement security best practices in JCL:

Never hardcode passwords in JCL
Use security tools like RACF, ACF2, or Top Secret for authentication
Minimize use of privileged accounts in jobs
Control access to JCL libraries and procedures
Audit production JCL changes regularly

Automation and Scheduling

Design JCL with automation in mind:

Use consistent return codes for job status reporting
Include dependencies in job documentation for schedulers
Implement standardized logging for automated monitoring
Consider restart requirements for automated recovery
Design for unattended execution with clear error handling

Continuous Improvement

Adopt practices that support ongoing enhancement:

Conduct regular reviews of critical JCL
Establish metrics for JCL quality and performance
Implement automated testing for JCL changes
Document lessons learned from incidents
Update standards based on experience and new capabilities

Standards should evolve over time. Regularly review and update your JCL standards to incorporate new techniques, address emerging challenges, and leverage platform enhancements.

Practical Exercise

Standardize and Improve a JCL Job

In this exercise, you'll review and enhance a JCL job to apply the standards and best practices you've learned.

Start with this poorly formatted and documented JCL:

jcl

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
//JB123 JOB 'ACCT',CLASS=A
//S1 EXEC PGM=SORT
//SORTIN DD DSN=INPUT.FILE,DISP=SHR
//SORTOUT DD DSN=OUTPUT.FILE,DISP=(NEW,CATLG),
//SPACE=(CYL,(5,2)),DCB=(RECFM=FB,LRECL=80,BLKSIZE=0)
//SYSIN DD *
 SORT FIELDS=(1,10,CH,A)
/*
//S2 EXEC PGM=IDCAMS
//DD1 DD DSN=OUTPUT.FILE,DISP=SHR
//SYSPRINT DD SYSOUT=*
//SYSIN DD *
 PRINT INFILE(DD1) CHAR
/*

Your task is to enhance this JCL by:

Adding comprehensive documentation including purpose, author, and date
Applying proper naming conventions for the job, steps, and datasets
Improving formatting with consistent indentation and alignment
Adding appropriate comments for each section
Implementing error handling with conditional logic
Including a change history section

Also consider how you would:

Implement version control for this job
Manage changes across development, test, and production environments
Make this job more modular using procedures or includes

Compare your enhanced JCL with examples in the next lesson to see different approaches to standardization.

Test Your Knowledge

1. Which of the following is a recommended JCL naming convention?

Use lowercase for all job names to reduce visual noise
Make all job names as long as possible to be descriptive
Use a consistent prefix that identifies the application or department
Randomly generate job names to ensure uniqueness

2. What is the primary purpose of JCL documentation standards?

To increase the file size of JCL code
To make the JCL harder to modify by others
To provide context and explanation for future maintainers
To satisfy audit requirements only

3. Which of the following is NOT a good JCL formatting practice?

Aligning similar statements for readability
Using consistent indentation for nested statements
Adding blank comment lines to separate logical sections
Putting multiple statements on the same line to save space

4. Why is version control important for JCL?

It makes JCL run faster on the mainframe
It tracks changes over time and enables rollback if needed
It automatically optimizes JCL performance
It prevents anyone from modifying the JCL

5. Which of the following is a best practice for JCL change management?

Make changes directly in production to save time
Test changes in lower environments before promoting to production
Always make changes during peak business hours
Avoid documenting what changes were made

Frequently Asked Questions

JCL Include (JCLLIB)JCL Performance Considerations