Troubleshooting Job Failures: ISPF Utilities & Edit Techniques

Troubleshooting job failures is a critical skill for mainframe operations. When jobs fail, you need to systematically identify the cause, understand error messages, and fix the issues. ISPF provides utilities and edit techniques that make troubleshooting efficient and effective. Understanding troubleshooting methods helps you resolve job failures quickly. This tutorial covers common failure types, using ISPF utilities for diagnosis, edit techniques for fixing issues, and systematic troubleshooting approaches.

Job failures can occur for many reasons: JCL syntax errors, missing datasets, insufficient resources, program errors, and system issues. ISPF provides integrated tools for viewing output, editing JCL, verifying datasets, and comparing versions. This tutorial provides practical guidance for troubleshooting job failures systematically.

Understanding Job Failures

Job failures occur when jobs cannot complete successfully.

What Causes Job Failures?

Common causes of job failures include:

• JCL Syntax Errors: Incorrect JCL statement format, missing commas, invalid parameters
• Dataset Issues: Dataset not found, insufficient space, authorization errors
• Program Errors: Program abends, invalid data, logic errors
• Resource Issues: Insufficient space, missing libraries, unavailable resources
• System Issues: System errors, timeouts, resource constraints

Failure Indicators

Signs that a job has failed:

• Non-zero return codes from steps
• Abend codes in output
• Error messages in job output
• Job status showing failure
• Missing expected output

Systematic Troubleshooting Approach

Following a systematic approach helps you troubleshoot efficiently.

Step 1: View Job Output

First, view the job output to see what happened:

• Access SDSF to view job output
• Check job status and completion code
• Review error messages
• Look for abend codes
• Check return codes from each step

Step 2: Identify the Failing Step

Identify which step failed:

• Check return codes for each step
• Find the first step with non-zero return code
• Review that step's output
• Note the step name and error

Step 3: Analyze the Error

Analyze the specific error:

• Read error messages carefully
• Understand abend codes if present
• Check for common error patterns
• Identify the root cause

Step 4: Fix the Issue

Fix the identified issue:

• Edit JCL to correct errors
• Fix dataset references if needed
• Correct syntax errors
• Adjust parameters as needed

Step 5: Verify and Resubmit

Verify fixes and resubmit:

• Review corrected JCL
• Resubmit the job
• Monitor job execution
• Verify successful completion

Common Failure Types

Understanding common failure types helps you troubleshoot effectively.

JCL Syntax Errors

JCL syntax errors include:

• Missing Commas: Commas required between parameters
• Incorrect Statement Format: Wrong statement structure
• Invalid Parameters: Parameters not recognized or invalid
• Missing Required Statements: Required statements omitted
• Incorrect Continuation: Continuation characters used incorrectly

Example of missing comma error:

1
2
3
//STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM CLASS=A MSGCLASS=X
//* Error: Missing comma between CLASS and MSGCLASS
//* Correct: //STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM,CLASS=A,MSGCLASS=X

Dataset Not Found Errors

Dataset not found errors occur when:

• Dataset name is misspelled
• Dataset doesn't exist
• Dataset is not cataloged
• Volume serial is incorrect
• Dataset is on different volume

Common error message: "IEF237I JOBNAME STEPNAME - DATA SET NOT FOUND"

Insufficient Space Errors

Insufficient space errors occur when:

• Primary allocation is too small
• Secondary allocation exhausted
• Volume is full
• Space allocation is insufficient for data

Common error message: "IEF233I JOBNAME STEPNAME - INSUFFICIENT SPACE"

Abend Codes

Common abend codes include:

• S013: Dataset not found
• S222: Insufficient space
• S806: Program not found
• S322: Timeout or cancellation
• S0C7: Data exception
• U4038: Authorization failure

Using ISPF Utilities for Troubleshooting

ISPF utilities provide tools for diagnosing issues.

Data Set Utility

Use Data Set Utility (Option 3.2) to:

• Verify dataset existence
• Check dataset attributes
• View dataset information
• List dataset contents
• Verify catalog entries

Browse Utility

Use Browse (Option 1) to:

• View job output datasets
• Review error messages
• Check log files
• Examine output content

Compare Utility

Use Compare Utility to:

• Compare JCL versions
• Find differences between working and failing JCL
• Identify what changed
• Verify corrections

Search Utility

Use Search Utility to:

• Search for error patterns
• Find specific error messages
• Locate problem areas in JCL
• Search across multiple members

Edit Techniques for Fixing JCL

ISPF Edit provides powerful techniques for fixing JCL errors.

Finding Errors

To find errors in JCL:

• Use FIND command to search for error messages
• Search for common error patterns
• Review JCL syntax visually
• Check for missing commas and parameters
• Verify statement format

Fixing Syntax Errors

To fix syntax errors:

• Add missing commas between parameters
• Correct statement format
• Fix parameter syntax
• Add missing required statements
• Correct continuation characters

Example: Fixing missing comma

1
2
3
4
5
// Before (Error):
//STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM CLASS=A MSGCLASS=X
 
// After (Fixed):
//STEP1    EXEC PGM=PROGRAM,CLASS=A,MSGCLASS=X

Fixing Dataset References

To fix dataset references:

• Verify dataset names are correct
• Check dataset exists using Data Set Utility
• Correct misspelled dataset names
• Add volume serial if needed
• Fix catalog references

Using Line Commands

Use line commands for efficient editing:

• I: Insert new lines
• D: Delete lines
• C: Copy lines
• M: Move lines
• R: Repeat lines

Using Primary Commands

Use primary commands for advanced editing:

• FIND: Search for text
• CHANGE: Replace text
• LOCATE: Find specific lines
• RESET: Reset edit session

Reading Error Messages

Understanding error messages is crucial for troubleshooting.

JCL Error Messages

Common JCL error message formats:

• IEF237I: Dataset not found
• IEF233I: Insufficient space
• IEF142I: Job cancelled
• IEF450I: JCL error

System Messages

System messages provide additional information:

• Abend codes and descriptions
• System resource information
• Authorization messages
• Dataset status messages

Program Messages

Program messages include:

• Application-specific errors
• Data validation messages
• Business logic errors
• Program diagnostic messages

Return Codes

Return codes indicate step completion status.

Understanding Return Codes

Return codes indicate:

• 0: Step completed successfully
• Non-zero: Step failed or had warnings
• Higher numbers often indicate more severe errors
• Some programs use specific return codes for specific errors

Checking Return Codes

To check return codes:

• View job output in SDSF
• Look for return code in step summary
• Check each step's return code
• Identify first failing step

Troubleshooting Workflow Example

Example troubleshooting workflow.

Scenario: Job Fails with Dataset Not Found

Step-by-step troubleshooting:

• 1. View job output in SDSF - see "IEF237I DATA SET NOT FOUND"
• 2. Identify failing step - STEP1 failed
• 3. Note dataset name from error - USERID.DATA.INPUT
• 4. Use Data Set Utility to verify dataset exists
• 5. Find dataset name is misspelled in JCL
• 6. Edit JCL to correct dataset name
• 7. Resubmit job
• 8. Verify job completes successfully

Best Practices

Following best practices helps you troubleshoot effectively:

• Start with Job Output: Always check job output first
• Work Systematically: Follow a systematic approach
• Fix One Issue at a Time: Address issues one by one
• Verify Before Resubmitting: Verify fixes before resubmitting
• Document Solutions: Keep notes on common issues and solutions
• Use Utilities: Leverage ISPF utilities for verification
• Compare with Working Versions: Compare with known working JCL
• Test Incrementally: Test fixes incrementally

Common Error Patterns

Recognizing common error patterns speeds up troubleshooting.

Pattern: Missing Comma

Symptoms: JCL syntax error, parameter not recognized

Solution: Add comma between parameters

Pattern: Dataset Not Found

Symptoms: IEF237I error, abend S013

Solution: Verify dataset name, check catalog, verify volume

Pattern: Insufficient Space

Symptoms: IEF233I error, abend S222

Solution: Increase space allocation, check volume space

Pattern: Program Not Found

Symptoms: Abend S806, program load error

Solution: Verify program name, check STEPLIB, verify library

Explain Like I'm 5: Troubleshooting Job Failures

Think of troubleshooting job failures like fixing a broken toy:

• Job Failure is like when your toy stops working. Something went wrong, and you need to figure out what. The job (toy) tried to do something but couldn't complete it. It's like when your remote control car stops moving - something is wrong!
• Viewing Output is like checking the instruction manual or looking at what the toy is doing. When you look at the job output, you see messages that tell you what went wrong, just like error lights or messages on your toy. It's like reading the manual to see what the problem might be!
• Finding the Error is like identifying which part of the toy is broken. You look at the error messages and figure out what specific thing went wrong - maybe a battery is dead, or a part is missing. It's like finding out that the remote control car's battery needs to be replaced!
• Fixing the Error is like repairing the toy. You fix the problem you found - replace the battery, fix the broken part, or adjust something. In JCL, you edit the code to fix the mistake. It's like putting in a new battery and making the car work again!
• Testing is like trying the toy again to make sure it works. After you fix the job, you submit it again to see if it works now. It's like testing the remote control car to make sure it moves after you fixed it!

So troubleshooting job failures is like being a detective who finds out what's wrong with a broken toy, fixes it, and tests it to make sure it works!

Practice Exercises

Complete these exercises to reinforce your troubleshooting skills:

Exercise 1: Identify Job Failure

Practice identification: submit a job with intentional error, view job output in SDSF, identify the failure type, understand error messages, and learn failure identification. Master failure identification.

Exercise 2: Fix JCL Syntax Error

Practice syntax: create JCL with syntax error, use ISPF Edit to find error, fix the syntax error, verify correction, and resubmit. Master syntax error fixing.

Exercise 3: Fix Dataset Error

Practice dataset: create JCL with dataset error, use Data Set Utility to verify dataset, fix dataset reference, verify fix, and resubmit. Master dataset error fixing.

Exercise 4: Use Compare Utility

Practice compare: compare working and failing JCL versions, identify differences, understand what changed, apply fixes, and learn comparison techniques. Master comparison.

Exercise 5: Complete Troubleshooting

Practice complete: troubleshoot a complex job failure, use multiple ISPF utilities, fix multiple issues, verify all fixes, and complete troubleshooting. Master complete troubleshooting.

Related Concepts